I had some doubts along the way that we'd actually get here, but! Here we are.
Voyager's last season aired from October of 2000 to May 2001. Were you watching? I wasn't. I think the only things I was watching regularly week-to-week in that time period were Dawson's and SNL.
There'll be at least one more post in this VOY series, then that may be it for Trek-blogs for awhile. Or maybe not. Originally I'd planned to start an immediate Enterprise season-by-season project. It'd be cool to do one of these season-by-season re-rankings for any of the other Treks, really, with the exception of TOS. (There's no such as "rewatch" with TOS - it's an ongoing watch - and I don't have much to add to any of those.) But they take forever.
For now let's just focus on the task at hand, and a-Voyager-ing let us go.
23.
Q leaves his son (Q2) on Voyager to learn from the crew.
Nope. The idea of even engaging with this annoys me. I don't know Voyager felt the need to go back to the Q well after insert-last-Q-episode-ever events, but here's another diminishing return for a pretty well-diminished-concept.
22.
Prisoners
are brought onto Voyager from a damaged alien vessel, and the crew must
deliver them to their destination – for execution. Seven's nanoprobes
are used to help heal a prisoner.
Where have I seen this guy before? (Answer: oh, it's Jeff Kober, from China Beach and elsewhere.) Where have we seen this episode before? Haven't they already done this on the show? Or am I just thinking of that TNG one from one of the earlier seasons?
Capital punishment stories are always a little awkward for me. Yedig doesn't persuade me. Is he meant to? Starts a little on the broad side and gets extensively broader. Wouldn't it have been more interesting if Yedig had been a liberal reformer of some kind?
It's not terrible, and there are some issues raised worth examining via Trek lens. Particularly the Clockwork Orange-ness of the nanoprobes. What exactly do they do? how can they restore someone's sense of empathy and moral compass when they're designed to suppress that in assimilated drones? I'm not knocking the idea - I think it could've been much more interestingly explored than what we got here.
21.
In
the future where it took Voyager 23 years to get home, Admiral Janeway
devises a plan to alter history. As the crew enters a final showdown
with the Borg, the two Janeways implement a risky plan to take out one
of the six Borg Transwarp Hubs in the galaxy and simultaneously cross
the transwarp threshold to get home.
Any Trek finale is getting in the ring with "All Good Things." (I'm just skipping over "Turnabout Intruder" and "The Counter-Clock Incident," neither of which were specifically crafted to be series finales.) I thought the DS9 finale was pretty good, although I only ever watched the first and last season and a handful of episodes in-between so maybe I'm not the one to say. But it seemed to do its job. Finales have to exemplify the spirit of all that came before, wrap up any long-running storylines, elevate everyone in the cast, and send things off in style. I can forgive the shortcomings of any finale that hits these marks, even if I don't like them.
"Endgame" isn't that finale. They opted for a retread of "All Good Things", right down to Tuvok's degenerative brain disease and the time displacement/ multiple Janeways. And not a very animated one at that. Worse, it hits so many cliches (the birth, the big 'splosions, the inexplicable new romance - Seven and Chakotay - yadda yadda) rather than trust in the show and cast's innate qualities. You know the scene in Bring It On where the girls realize their dance routine is identical to the one that just wowed the crowd, but they do it anyway, satisfying no one? That's "Endgame."
Another thing that gets me: Janeway's (and Trek time travel) inconsistencies re: moral imperatives, the timeline, and Borg are something else. Definitely not the note you want to hit on the way out the door.
There are things I like. Harry Kim as Captain of the USS Rhode Island? Awesome. And giving him the redemptive moment of having been the one to correctly guess the way home is a nice touch, too. I like the return of Alice Krige, even if she's not given much to work with. The transwarp conduit is... well, it looks cool. But the assimilation-infection-back-up plan: I can't believe they still talk about this. Like the cloaking device, surely the Borg have adapted by now; Starfleet talks about this all the time. Are you telling me an enemy who adapts to phaser frequencies within thirty seconds can somehow remain oblivious to the danger of this plan over years and years and years of its being tried? Trek can be so weird about things like that - or having some big fuck-off ship appear like we're all supposed to be impressed or something. Always blown up with a single torpedo. Who makes these decisions?
Also: Janeway didn't even try to beam/ rescue Admiral Janeway. This is at least the 2nd alternate Janeway she's let die, geez.
20.
Ex-Maquis crew members are attacked after a data stream arrives from Starfleet.
A little late in the show to be doing this episode. Maybe the Maquis and the Kazon can get together and pool their resources into a concept I care an iota about; they'd need to. Not a bad episode but I struggled to remain interested in watching it. I liked the movie theater stuff, that's about it.
19.
Voyager's
hologram technology, which Janeway had previously donated to the
Hirogen, has been modified to make the holographic "prey" more cunning,
enabling the hologram characters to rebel against their new masters.
Titlewise, we get "Flesh and Blood" and "Body and Soul" in the same season. Seems a little lazy. Couldn't anyone come up with anything else? I always wonder with these things if it's a writer's-union sort of thing, like to do so engages machinery that is the exact opposite of a quick two-second fix.
I suppose your reaction to this one all depends what you think of this all-holograms-working-together sort of thing. And whether this season can support 2 two-parters that seem born of recycling costumes. Myself, I think the former is strained or doesn't realize itself well enough - again, BSG comes to mind as the road better taken - and I do not for the latter. The dilemma for Janeway isn't really apt: the holograms are who they are because of the Hirogen's adjustments, not because they shared the technology. The heavy sense of responsibility she feels is a little too forced. Obviously I see what they're going for (and it's an exploration very much in the Trek tradition, all the way back to Kirk's "serpents for the garden of Eden" poetics at the end of "A Private Little War") but it doesn't land with me here.
18.
Janeway,
B'Elanna and Tuvok are assimilated by the Borg while attempting to save
the group of drones who have developed individuality.
I covered this one last time but worth a mention here as well. I apologize for my lack of consistency with the two-parters I condense into one entry and the ones I treat separately.
For a story that ends with the Borg Civil War, which just kind of fades into the background of s7 after this episode, and features the Borg Queen destroying several of her own ships, and Tuvok getting assimilated, or whatever-you-like, it sure feels like we've seen all this before. I can't pinpoint exactly what it is, but there's just an aura of been-there-done-that to all we see. The tete-a-tete between Janeway and the Borg Queen has its moments, as do some of the moments between Seven and Axum (played by Mark Deakins, who was in Insurrection).
The production design choices re: the Borg get-ups are interesting. Cool sub-processor effect on B'Elanna's voice but why not the others?
17.
When her cortical implant malfunctions, Seven of Nine needs a life-saving transplant.
The Delta Flyer, so recently offered up as a sacrifice in "Unimatrix Zero" is replicated and back in action. Like many Voyager watchers, I've poked some fun at Chakotay's losing so many shuttles over the years, or their having an inconsistent approach with what they can or can't replicate. Mostly that's a pretty mild offense - there are "magic" elements of Trek, and the replicator is certainly one of them. That said, it might've helped the show a tad more had shuttles and Delta Flyers been harder to come by.
Icheb for the win this whole episode. Touching ending. I think there was definitely an element of awkward men and women working out adolescent issues in some aspects of Berman-era Trek. In thoughtful if sometimes clunky ways. Overall positive. It's a nice counterpoint to the other trends of 90s programming, i.e. a general slide then spike towards tortureporn and nihilism. Imperfection(s), indeed.
16.
Now
married to Tom Paris, B'Elanna Torres discovers she is pregnant. The
Doctor tells her to expect a daughter; but B'Elanna's unresolved fear of
the childhood traumas, which she suffered as a part-Klingon girl
growing up among humans, makes her determined to remove her child's
Klingon DNA.
Here's the bulletpoints from my now-retired Voyager notepad:
- Klingons have a 30 week pregnancy. I'm enough of a nerd to want to check that against any/ all other references, but not enough of one to actually do the legwork. Something to shoot for!
- The flashbacks don't quite deliver the Lost/Watchmen effect here. Like the earlier Tuvok one. (I can't recall the name offhand, the one with Tank Girl.)
- Tom Paris has a toaster? I'm not surprised.
- Kind of an uncomfortabe one. But an honest attempt, at least, to deal with the mixed (ahem) legacy of half-human hybrids in Trek and their analogs in the non-trek (i.e. real) world. Also, the well, whiteness of the franchise, while staying within the ideological framework of the show.
- The only problem is it feels a bit of a regression for B'Elanna's character. Much like Harry with "Nightingale," I had a sort of paternal reaction, like I thought it was a cruel use of the character just to put the (admittedly worthwhile) issue on display. It didn't feel developed enough. The flashbacks like I say were integrated rather awkwardly, not as effective as they could have been.
- I do like very much the Doc's being chosen as the godfather.
15.
Harry Kim takes command of an alien ship that has lost its officers in an attack.
We've heard all of this before, right down to Tom and Harry in the corridor. Little late in this show for this type of episode/ Harry-arc. But this would've made a fine transition-Harry-out-of-perpetual-ensign episode back in s3 or s4. In a way, there's part of me that responded to this episode in an almost offended way, like it's tough to see Harry keep getting treated like this. Ridiculous I know.
Ron Glass! |
Poor Icheb. Poor Harry. (Icheb's arc is the fun part of the episode. Although I kind of enjoy most of the Nightingale story, too.) |
14.
Seven practices her social skills on the holodeck.
Perfectly fine, but as with "Nightingale," a little late in the series for this type of thing. Some more fun stuff from Icheb. If I were in charge of Paramount, I'd have made 3 or 4 Icheb movies by now. With Neelix. Man that'd piss people off - but they'd all be awesome, so everyone would begrudgingly admit I was right. And I'd be loaded.
Sorry, had some trouble disengaging my holodeck program from interfering with my duties, there. Should be fine now.
13.
The
crew of Voyager enters the Delta Flyer in a sub-warp race, crewed by
Tom Paris and B'Elanna Torres, and events conspire to encourage Tom to
propose to her.
Mostly fine, although I personally found the juxtaposition of relationship-race stuff with flying-the-race stuff to be a little pat. Harmless enough - perhaps the genre (racing drama) demands the car vs. betty dynamic, I don't know, along with the cheating-mustachioced-villain.
The race itself could have been more dazzling. The premise is in never in any danger of being over-exploited; they charted a rather bland-but-safe passage right through. Rather disappointing, that, but I suppose not everything has to be a gamechanger. It speaks to the difficulty of the "hotshot pilot" scenes in Trek. It just never really works. Piloting shuttlecrafts and starships is just never exciting the way the scripts want it to be.
12.
A hologram of Reginald Barclay is sent to Voyager, supposedly to implement a dangerous plan to bring them home; but the hologram has been tampered with by some Ferengi, who are trying to steal valuable Borg nanoprobes from Seven of Nine.
Maybe too much Barclay, now, especially with Troi always combined with him.
But, a good variation of the concept, and Schultz was a fun character actor who chewed scenery well. Picardo and he were well-matched onscreen.
11.
Voyager encounters
an ancient Klingon battlecruiser. The Klingons aboard it had set out
long ago to find their savior, and they believe it to be Tom and
B'Elanna's unborn child.
More Alpha Quadrant.
More Alpha Quadrant.
More bulletpoints:
- 2nd episode where the shyuttle cargo bay is converted (200 mouths to feed. That replicator is getting a workout.)
- Neelix and Tuvok: the spin-off Odd Couple reboot-gold that never happened.
- I'm a sucker for this type of story. I'm probably overranking it.
- When challenged to a death match, with a Klingon or otherwise, you always accept.
That training montage could have really used some more montage-appropriate music. VOY never went off-model like that, though, and it would've been odd for them do suddenly do so in s7. Still! You're the best! A-ROUND! (insert Klingon for the rest)
- Nehret: magic hybrid stem cells! Always with the magic blood in these things. I suppose that was a trope long before Star Trek or 20th century sci-fi altogether.
- Wouldn't the Klingons demand Tom and B'Elanna stay with them? And then Tom and B'Elanna would be elevated as royalty or protected persons or something? Wouldn't mind a sequel where their daughter-to-be seeks these guys out. With Neelix. And Icheb. And Tuvok and Old Harry Kim, who's still an ensign.
10.
The
crew is sent on its first mission by Starfleet in nearly seven years:
to find a lost probe sent by Earth in the 21st century that has ended up
in the Delta Quadrant.
Definitely a bit of a John Carpenter homage with this one. And a successful enough one, I think. Also a TWOK/ Botany Bay vbe.
Fun set-up. Not a bad version of this sort of thing. All too true of a wrap-up at the end.
9.
While
visiting the planet Ledos, Seven and Chakotay crash through an energy
barrier. The two are stranded in the jungle with primitive humanoids,
who take the pair in and care for Chakotay's injuries. To rejoin
Voyager, he and Seven have to disable the energy barrier.
Chakotay loses a shuttle! And he and 7 are paired so soon after 7's Chakotay-kissing-practice on the holodeck. Pretty good. Some might think it gets a little preachy. Maybe so - I thought it was mostly uncontroversial stuff. The ending would've worked a little better against a waves backdrop, like leaving the island's beauty.
Tom's whole subplot with the driving test: a shameless pitch to their fanbase/ demographic. But, hardly the first of those in either Trek or TV history, nor the last.
8.
During
an emergency on a mission, The Doctor is forced to upload his program
into Seven of Nine's Borg implants, allowing him to experience real
sensations for the first time.
Great Picardo impersonation from Jeri Ryan.
Great Picardo impersonation from Jeri Ryan.
Why do aliens say 'the Delta Quadrant'? I guess the answer is simply the universal translator. In a way it's an elegant solution: no matter what people call their own worlds, the universal translator translate it all into a grid of language (especially with regard to planetary systems and names). It's by no means perfect, though, or really that comprehensible. These are all Captain-Obvious statements to make to any Trek fan, of course.
A better question is: why are there no cameras in the brig?
This could have went somewhere a bit more with the attraction to the lady - also, who IS that lady? It's Megan Gallagher, another alum (like Picardo) of China Beach. How come Voyager never got Dana Delaney?
Is Picardo just employing actor-ly mannerisms in his performance of the Doctor, easily teachable to Ryan or anyone else, the way a cartoonist's style can be taught as an in-house style? |
Or perhaps Ryan is just a master impressionist, which is the likelier case - we've seen her do many different characters already on the show. |
I'm not 100% up on her post-VOY career, but my impression is that those types of talents have perhaps been squandered. Even in VOY episodes I'm not crazy about (like the one where she splits into different people) it's easy to see she had a talent for this sort of thing. She would've worked well on a show like Dollhouse. Hindsight.
I'm skipping over the Pon Farr stuff. While a good callback, it seemed like kind of a letdown. Does Tuvok really need to be persuaded of the logic of utilizing the holodeck to avoid his own death from sexual frustration?
7.
Voyager is pulled into a void, where the ships that have become trapped attack each other for food and resources.
This is another one I remember well from my insomnia Voyager watching way back when. It struck me then as a successful utilization of the concept, and so it strikes me now. Interesting, differentiated aliens, Federation principles tested against isolation, survival of the ship so far from home in the unknown, etc. Good contrast with the abundance of food vs. losing 90s% of their food stores in the initial raid.
Nice score and sound design in this one, as well.
6.
Voyager
is fractured into several time periods by an accident, and only
Chakotay is able to move between them, in the process meeting old
friends and old foes from the previous six seasons
Fun deal. The gel-pack thing is maggufintastic. But who cares.
Icheb and Naomi Wildman are cool. But 17 years... I have questions. |
Nice moment between Janeway and Chakotay. |
I never liked Seska but kind of nice to see the actress again and the passage of time almost makes me nostalgic to see the Kazon. I'm sorry - sometimes I say things.
One thing, though: how would Chakotay telling Janeway about the epsode's plot be against the Temporal Prime Directive? Obviously these are all alternate timeliness. Not knowledge of the future. Oh yeah: the TPD is nonsense. My fault for asking.
5.
The Doctor is forced to help aliens steal Voyager's warp core.
I seem to have lost my notes for this one. I didn't write much, just how this kind of story was getting a little repetitive for The Doctor. But how could they stop? They're always so much fun. Even if I find a lot of it to be better expressed in other Doctor episodes. it's engaging from start to finish.
Nice to see Vorik again. Did it really take me until just now to realize his parents are Jeri Taylor (Voyager co-creator) and Dick Enberg? Sheesh. I probably learned and forgot that 3 or 4 times now, I bet. The perils of covering a series over 2 years.
It's an odd choice for the penultimate episode of the entire series. Personally, I'd have gone with "Author, Author."
4.
The
Voyager crew is brainwashed into taking new jobs on an industrialized
planet that has a severe labor shortage, leaving only Chakotay, Kim and
Neelix (who were on an away mission) and the Doctor (who, in the absence
of the crew, has become the Emergency Command Hologram) to save them.
Chakotay and Neelix take jobs on the new planet, and try to rescue their
amnesiac crewmates – who don't want to leave.
Ambitious. Like "Year of Hell" but much more focused. The alien species set-up is kind of undeveloped, but it's just-developed-enough to get the story across. I like it as a metaphor, which I assume is all it's meant to be, but a metaphor for what, specifically, I don't really know. (Actors and roles? Re-entering the workforce after Trek? A vague sort of swipe at capitalism?) Whatever the case, some fun moments. There always are with brain-wipe plots. Also, plenty of inconsistencies.
Perhaps it might've been tied into that management-class-alien-species from the health care episode (coming up next incidentally - spoiler alert!) That'd have been cool.
3.
The
Doctor's program is stolen and he is forced to work in an alien
hospital, where he skillfully manipulates the system to provide ethical
medical care.
Classic Trek with all that entails. I bet there are those who feel the Doctor's actions, here, aren't correct, or that the writers fumble the debate in an alienating way. I don't, but I can sympathize with the proverbial viewer who does. This engages me on a Trek level (alien-hospitals and space kidnapping, etc.), theater-level (good performances from President Logan and all the rest) and a compelling, engaging topic, explored within accessible dramatic limits. And I like what it brings up and how it does so. Really, the people of the future's health care issues are more or less solved. Anything the replicator or transporter can't take care of is fixed up by McCoy's magic spray bottles. I like that the people of Trek are (Tom Paris notwithstanding) consistently appalled when confronted with societal conditions resembling our own.
With one notable exception, of course.
"I miss the Earth so much..." |
2.
The
Doctor writes a holo-novel to be published in the Alpha Quadrant,
featuring characters who closely resemble – but do not flatter – the
crew.
You'd think there were no more stories to tell about the Doctor's narcissism, but here we are. And despite some of the this-again ness of this, like most of the Doctor episodes, I'm too busy enjoying myself to mind too much. Let's face it: part of the reason Voyager feels after awhile like it's top-heavy towards the Doctor (or Seven of Nine episodes) is because they're the most fun. I like all the cast of the show and all the characters, too, but they had two exceptional performers in Robert Picardo and Jeri Ryan. Not taking anyone from anyone else, of course.
The story might have been developed a bit more or in a different direction, something like "Blood of Chaotica" or "Tinker Tenor". Really it's a very simple structure and comes across almost as fan service in some ways, but like I often say any multiple-seasons show has to give the actors new ways to blow off steam once in awhile.
I put this one under that umbrella. |
I forgot about the very ending of this one, with all the mk1 Picardos (referenced in "Life Line"). |
1.
Voyager encounters a Talaxian settlement leaving Neelix with the difficult decision of whether to leave the crew.
I can't believe I'm about to say this, but this is possibly the most heroic of all the send-offs outside Spock's original death in TWOK for any Trek character. It actually made me want to see some kind of movie with Neelix as the main character, which I thought wouldn't just be impossible pre-this-project but evidence of actual insanity if uttered aloud. So kudos to all involved on that. I'm happy to discover I can even change my mind about such a thing in my advanced age.
This one isn't the most original perhaps - the world or the dilemma - but the familiar as tweaked / run through some fun Trek tropes. Congratulations, Neelix, you get my vote for most memorable/ favorite of season 7.
~
Join me for one last Delta Quadrant go-round
next time with Voyager: My Top 20 Episodes.
next time with Voyager: My Top 20 Episodes.
(1) "Repentance" is an episode I kinda, sorta, don't mind, while also noting the criticisms that can be leveled at it. Perhaps it's telling that I just watch it for the hell of it, and tune out a lot of the debates.
ReplyDeleteThe idea of Voyager going Clockwork Orange with this scenario is now perhaps one of the great never to be known what ifs.
(2) I'm going to have to come back to "Endgame". The reason is its one of those things where my mind has multiple reactions, some less charitable than others. The problem is I don't think I ever really organized these thoughts into coherent form. Or is that just the result of the episode itself? One of those, anyway. Like I say, I'll have to come back to it someday, maybe.
(3) Your talk about magic in Trek reminds me of one of the great criticisms to be lobbed at the Harry Potter series. The criticism is that by utilizing magic so much, the writer tends to create too many get out of jail free cards. This can be ironic when fans can spot ways that this dramatic device can be used in more creative ways than the writer was able to formulate.
I don't think "Voyager", as a whole, ever quite arrived at that level, yet it's probably close.
(4) Another unknowable what if. "Unimatrix Zero" was originally supposed to be about Seven reconnecting with her father, while helping him take down the Borg from within.
I can't say such an idea was any more creative than what we got. However, it might at least have had a greater emotional resonance. This could have been easily conveyed Ryan, given enough good writing that played to her strengths as an actor (and she might have just been the most talented performer on that set, alongside Picardo).
(5) Perhaps "Workforce" could have benefited from like a "Milt" character (has anyone else here seen "Office Space"?) who winds up the big hero at the end.
(6) I can't say I mind "Human Error" all that much.
ChrisC
(4) I didn't know that about "Unimatrix Zero." Very interesting.
DeleteI like them all, and no disrespect to any of them, but I agree: Ryan and Picardo were the real dynamos of that cast.
I missed the Milton joke up there first time around. Agreed! Heck, they should've just cut to Stephen Root at the end, burning down the house, no explanation needed.
Delete😴
ReplyDeleteThat's just what the ancient Hebrews thought.
Delete"Unimatrix Zero Part II" --
ReplyDeleteSnoozefest. Kate Mulgrew isn't even particularly good in this, which is when you know things have taken a turn for the dull. It's not a terrible episode, but there was literally not one single scene that engaged me. The closest we got was the bit in which Tom tries to play argumentative-fist-officer with Chakotay, but even that is only so-so.
Dull covers it. I didn't realize what Chris wrote up there about the original idea being Seven meeting/ working with her father. I don't know if it'd have saved things. It's weird to be watching the Borg episodes of TNG and realizing they more or less spun their wheels with the concept after only a handful of appearances.
DeleteI guess at the bottom of things, it's just a limited concept (the Borg in general, not just the Unimatrix Zero idea). I still think they should have more or less called it quits on it after "The Best of Both Worlds," because there's no topping that. "I Borg" is a great spin on it, and that led us to Seven, who is arguably one of the great Trek characters; so I guess those facts argue against what I'm saying.
DeleteI think the problem "Voyager" ended up running into was that many of its big Borg moves really consisted only of mimicking those TNG episodes. And the movie "First Contact." The best wrinkle they added was probably the one involving Species 8472, i.e., what happens when the Borg run into someone more powerful than they are?
That's an interesting bit of trivia about "Unimatrix Zero" originally being intended to focus on Seven's father. I'm immediately more interested in that, because it's character-centric. So is the as-produced version, in theory; in execution, not so much. The guy they cast is utterly bland, but in his defense, there's nothing on the page for him to work with. At no point do these episodes make you feel anything about him, or about Seven's alleged feelings for him; it's a complete waste of space.
Still, this isn't bad so much as it's just a missed opportunity.
Good points, definitely.
Delete"Repression" --
ReplyDelete(1) Did I miss the part where they explained why this brainwashing of Tuvok's was only now coming to the surface? I must have.
(2) The movie-theatre stuff is fun, but I'll eat my hat if that is actually based on a Chicago theatre from the thirties. That's so small it's just about got to be a redressed screening room at the studio lot. Screens were not, so far as I know, made that tiny in the thirties; that's a modern-day abomination, er, invention.
(3) I had to Google it to remember whether Keith Szarabajka also played this role on Deep Space Nine. He evidently did not, so thank you, Google.
(1) Me too. Anyone else out there? Bueller...? Bueller...?
Delete(2) In a way I'm happy to see the people of the future exaggerating or just flat-out getting wrong things of the past. It fits the general trend of how people recreate/ think of things 500 years in the past.
(2) That's a great point, actually.
Delete"Imperfection" --
ReplyDelete(1) This one is solid. I like the final note of Seven's ocular implant "malfunctioning" again, except nope, she's legit crying this time.
(2) I was shocked by the moment in which Janeway suggested they just go hunt 'em up a live Borg and take what they needed. Katie, you been remembering that time that Vidian dude stole Neelix's lung?!? Not a good thing to emulate. But it's clearly just a temporary bit of anger coming out. I like that they let Janeway be a complete dick for a minute or two every once in a while. That's a nice, realistic way to go.
(3) Since they were just Borgs themselves a little while ago, do Janeway, B'Elanna, and Tuvok now have cortical implants to have to deal with? Nah, probably not, I think the writers probably opted to more or less forget "Unimatrix Zero" the second it was over. I can't blame them too much.
(4) Thanks again, "Picard," for that Icheb plotline. You fuck-sacks.
(2) Janeway is so damn inconsistent when it comes to the Borg. Is it a human, realistic thing? Or just sloppiness?
Delete(4) Yep. Worser still: the complete "Icheb?" or "Oh was that someone from another show?" reactions from people.
"Drive" --
ReplyDelete(1) I was briefly tempted to list a bunch of stuff related to the Ryan Gosling movie "Drive" but realized that's a dumb idea, and also that I don't remember enough about it to make it work. Great movie, though, I should watch it again.
(2) This one's okay. The premise of everyone flying through space in seemingly straight lines probably makes scientists want to punch themselves in the eyes, but hey, tv.
(3) I vacillate on the subject of Tom Paris. Sometimes I think he is a complete tool -- such as his complete ball-drop on the subject of his romantic getaway with B'Elanna -- and sometimes I think he's alright. I thought he was pretty much alright when he realized how distressed B'Elanna was and just stopped the race altogether. Good move, Tom.
(4) Harry Kim is even more hapless than poor old Geordie LaForge, and that is saying something.
(5) I had the sense that I'd seen Cyia Batten somewhere before, and yes, she was one of the Orion women in "Bound" during season four of Enterprise. AND played Dukat's daughter on a DS9. So evidently they liked her pretty well at Star Trek, and I do not blame them one bit.
(1) We can't go on thinkin' nuttttthing's wrong... oh my... who's gonna plug your ears? when youuuuuuuu screamm-m-m-m....
Delete(2) Imagine how cool this concept would've been had they just embraced some low-budget "Stun Runner" type scenario? Or anything that was better than straight lines in space? Gaaa.
(3) and (4) I'm with you.
(5) Berman-era Trek was great at re-using people in different parts.
Watched some VOYAGER last night, eh? Good man.
Yep, I'm typically only watching one episode at a time right now but for whatever reason felt moved to take in several at a go. Wouldn't've minded watching another, either.
Delete(1) The superior joke has arrived!
(2) I think they were still trying to appeal to wrestling fans at this point in the history of UPN, so I guess there's that.
"Critical Care" --
ReplyDelete(1) This one's great, and I'm glad you mentioned how TOS-esque it is. That idea was in the back of my brain someplace, but I never got it to come forward -- but yeah, for sure, it would be easy to imagine McCoy being the doctor instead of the Doctor himself.
(2) This one was written by James Kahn, whom I best know as the author of movie novelizations like "Return of the Jedi" and "Poltergeist." Maybe he had an old-school mentality that is part of what accounts for the way this feels like classic Trek.
(3) You shouldn't hire a guy like Larry Drake and then put him in a shiny form-fitting onesie. That's a no from me, dog. And then there's also the fat guy whose ex-wife shit-talks him -- for being fat! -- to Janeway, too. Not a good episode for the overweight.
(4) I liked Neelix's trick with the food, although here's one of those occasional times when I wish Trek of this era had been a bit less polite. Because really, what you want to see there is this guy crapping his pants. Just filling 'em right up over and over; or at least an explicit threat that that is going to happen. And I guess that's the logical conclusion to draw, I just wanted to hear Neelix say, "Have fun shitting yourself a lot, fella." And for Tuvok to raise an eyebrow and nod sagely.
(2) I hadn't noticed that! I had both those novelizations you mention, and I read that ROTJ novelization before even seeing the movie, thanks to the delay in first-run movies getting overseas in 1983. (I might even have only seen it in 1984, can't quite recall.) Either way I definitely read that Kahn novelization - more than twice.
Delete(3) I often decry how body shape fascism has a stranglehold on the industry, particularly in 2020 and just how weirdly accepted it is by people. One need only look at twentieth century TV/movies to see normal-looking people. And yet, I hear you: when I see some of these guest actors forced into Trek-ian one-sies or outfits to accentuate their man-boobs, I feel bad for them. A recent episode of TNG I watched ("Face of the Enemy") had the saddest-sack-looking (and quite pear-shaped) character guest actor and I was just like, did this guy lose a bet? Is he someone the TNG brass hated or something? Why would anyone do this to this guy?
"Inside Man" --
ReplyDelete(1) Schultz is pretty great in this one. He gets to play the holographic Reg as what Barclay would be like if he could actually be as confident as he wished. But since Barclay has no actual idea what confidence is, it's like the hollowest confidence you've ever seen in your life. Except because the hologram doesn't know how NOT to be what he's programmed to be, it's also genuine! A slippery idea, but Schultz nails it. And then nails it doubly when he's playing the real Barclay pretending to be the hologram.
(2) Sorry to be that guy, but this entire episode was worthwhile for the scene of Troi in a bikini.
(3) I got a kick out of the scene at the end where Tom and B'Elanna mess with Harry for being gullible. The Iconians indeed...! What a sucker!
(1) I agree, a lot of subtle dynamics in play here, and Dwight Schultz put in a pretty seamless performance. He and Picardo play well off each other.
ReplyDelete(2) I believe it's a one-piece! But I quibble.
(3) I missed that! Nice callback.
"Body and Soul" --
ReplyDelete(1) Not, like, a GREAT episode or anything, but pretty fun from beginning to end. Totally worth it just for the Jeri Ryan performance. I agree, her post-Trek career ought to have been more varied. She's reliable in just about any mode.
(2) The Tuvok stuff fascinates me. The very idea of pon farr is pretty doofy, to be honest; it mainly seems like it was designed to give pent-up Trekkies something to rub one out to while writing fanfic in the early seventies. I mean, Spock is going mad with the need to mate, then he "fights" with Kirk for a little while and he's all good again...? Okay, well, if you say so. Don't get me wrong, I love "Amok Time."
All of which is a long way to say that you are absolutely correct, it makes no sense for Tuvok to have to be coaxed into seeking this solution. There would be no logical reason for Vulcans to suppress knowledge about pon farr. It makes a sort of sense for Spock to do so, in theory; he's maybe a little ashamed of some of his Vulcan tendencies (as he is of his human tendencies). But for Tuvok? That's dumb. Just another example of how few Trek writers understand -- or care -- what logic actually is.
(3) Viewed from another angle, though, it makes sense that this is how they did it. Still a story flaw, but it's more understandable. In the eyes of some of Trek's producers -- or maybe some of the studio people -- sexuality is seen as a fundamentally illogical process. So in their eyes, a "logical" character like Tuvok must also be a repressed and repressive character. Therefore, the idea to get that poison out via (one assumes) holographic rough trade cannot come from Tuvok himself; it must come from a depraved mind like that of the ultra-human Tom Paris.
(4) Always happy to see Megan Gallagher! I should probably watch "China Beach" one of these days, if only for the cast.
(1) (2) (3) and (4) Agreed all around.
DeleteI enjoyed watching China Beach when I revisited 4 or 5 years ago. The cast was definitely solid and fun.
"Nightingale" --
ReplyDelete(1) I had the same reaction to you regarding the Harry storyline: offended on his behalf; should have happened seasons ago (if at all); etc. I'd add that it is extra offensive for him to get talked down to -- in the guise of instruction -- by Seven. That felt like a thing that somebody in the writer's room felt had to happen simply because she was the more important character of the two to the franchise. All of that felt off to me. At the same time, I thought Garrett Wang was good in the episode, so I enjoyed it from that perspective.
(2) Man, that Icheb plotline made me want to crawl out of my skin. When he confronted B'Elanna and said that her interest in him was inappropriate, I literally had to just grab my phone and check my email for a minute or two.
(3) You make a good point about the cloaking device. It doesn't seem as if it actually works at all, so I have no idea why it's a big deal. I also have no idea why Janeway permitted further Starfleet involvement after the initial incident Kim prompted. That's just not something it seems like she would do. Did they just give up writing her at some point? It feels a bit as if the Janeway of the first few seasons kind of disappeared at some point and I'm only now noticing.
(1) Good call on the Seven angle. That's true.
DeleteWe've got a ways before we'll hear them talk about this one on 'The Delta Flyers' I guess.
I wonder if they'll have Jeri Ryan or anyone else on as guests? I hope so.
(2) Team Icheb!
(3) You're not wrong at all re: Janeway. She's inconsistent as hell the last few seasons.
"Flesh and Blood" --
ReplyDelete(1) Yawn.
(2) Guaranteed that one week from now, I won't be able to remember which episode is "Body and Soul" and which is "Flesh and Blood."
(3) I agree with you regarding Janeway's guilt arc. Not only does it not make much sense logically, it's also poorly explored. It's really only explored much at all in the final scene, and that scene is so awkwardly staged (poor angles) that it's hard to concentrate on anything else. Or it was for me. Granted, I was just ready for the episode to be over by that point.
(4) I tend to enjoy the episodes that explore the ramifications of holo-technology, so in theory this one ought to have worked for me. But there's really nothing interesting about what they're doing here. The big advancements are that the one guy turns out to be a shitheel and the one lady turns out not to be. So basically they're just like organics? Some are good and some are bad? If you pitch that idea as some kind of revelation, maybe you've got something. But this? This is a bunch of nothing.
(2) When I saw which episode you were commenting on, I had to look it up. "Body and Soul" I remember as the Jeri Ryan episode, so that one is a bit more distinctive for me, at least for now. Ask me again in six months.
Delete(4) Yeah me too! Extra points deducted - they took something I'm usually quite forgiving with and did nothing with it. Like you say, this ain't much of a revelation. I remember something when Timmy Leary died that came out, a poorly made tribute of some kind of another, can't remember much details, but in it they asked him what his philosophy was, or basically gave him the microphone to say something profound and he was like "Think for yourself." And I was like... what? Granted he was an old man, but sheesh: no one needed a documentary made to hear someone espouse such a platitude as their grand statement. I'm reminded of another movie now, the Monkees' HEAD, where Davy sticks up for Peter and Peter's Zen-like sermonizing, until he gets to the end and says "But who am I? I am no one, and I know nothing" and Davy says "You mean I've been sitting here listening to this guy and this guy knows nothing?" which then cues the fisticuffs/ wacky-melee sequence.
I am digressing - the coffee is flowing! - but same deal. I feel like fighting people over such platitudes when presented to me thus.
"Shattered" --
ReplyDelete(1) Yeah, I'm with you; WHY does it violate the TPD to tell current-timeline Janeway about the timelines that were avoided? That don't make no sense.
(2) It also don't make no sense that alterna-past Janeway would sign on to her-future-Chakotay's plan, because why would she be willing to wipe her own timeline out of existence?
(3) This is a fun episode, but I don't know that it withstands any scrutiny. But hey, it's a decent Chakotay episode, and those don't come around all that often after a certain point. So I'll give it a mild thumbs up.
I guess I liked this one more than I remember since I placed it up at #6 but my memory has it being more of a shrug. I liked the idea of a ship in different timelines and one guy moving between them more than the execution. Like you say, fun episode, doesn't bear much scrutiny. And that's okay.
Deletep.s. Since switching to Comments Moderation to deal with the uptick of spam-comments lately, I've discovered that I don't always get a notice of a comment pending moderation. I clicked "pending moderation" (and it looked like the folder was empty) yesterday and saw, like, four or five TNG comments from you. I hit publish on each of them, but sorry for the delay/ missing them! I guess I have to train myself to check that Pending folder every so often.
DeleteI try to remember to check that myself every once in a while, but I rarely have any do that. It's not unheard of, though. Might have something to do with the changes to the system, as well.
Delete"Lineage" --
ReplyDelete(1) I like this one more than you do, but I see your point about it being a bit of a regression for the character. I'm willing to let that slide for a couple of reasons. First, I like B'Elanna, and while this feels in some ways like an episode we should have gotten seasons ago, I like it as an explanation for why she's so aggressive and withdrawn at the same time. Not always, granted; but frequently. It feels like screenwriter James Kahn might have had this idea about B'Elanna as a fan for quite some time and then finally found himself with a job on the show and pushed the story out even though it did set the clock on her back a bit.
The second reason I'll forgive it is that it can, in story terms, be chalked up to body chemistry gone nutso. I don't much care for that as an explanation and would have bucked against it if the screenplay itself had gone far in that direction; but it's one of those things I can just sort of leave running in the background mentally and let it soak up some of the objections.
(2) I'd wholly forgotten that bit at the end with her asking the Doctor to be the godfather. Perfectly played by both actors, and the kind of genuinely great moment you can (and even sometimes do!) get from a long-running series.
(3) And actually, almost everyone is given something nice to do like that. Chakotay gets to be a wise-uncle type; Janeway's scene in which she refuses to go against her CMO's recommendations is prototypical Janeway; Harry plays the clarinet; and Tom is pretty great throughout.
(1) Fair enough. It's not a bad episode, and it's a heart-in-the-right-place attempt. I shudder to think how the story would be handled or resolved these days.
Delete(2) I'll take this opportunity to say I'm enjoying the Voyager rewatch podcast Tom and Harry are doing, and everytime they bring up Robert Picardo it has to do with his having some statuesque girlfriend. The Seven/ Doctor chemistry makes even more sense. Anyway: everyone who meets that guy (Picardo) seems to fall in love with him.
(1) God and the man Jesus, so do I. I'm sure I'll have occasion to find out, eventually.
Delete(2) Yep, it's a solid podcast. I thought of that while rewatching this episode, too, except in my case I was just curious what McNeill will have to say. As for Picardo, he popped up in a tiny role on an episode of "Taxi" I watched the other night, and then again on an episode of "Justified" I watched. He was, unsurprisingly, memorable in both. So I say let him have a couple of statuesque blondes, he's earned 'em.
"Repentance" --
ReplyDelete(1) I don't think it's a classic or anything like that, but I do like this one pretty well. Good call on the Clockwork Orange-ness; that did not occur to me, but it should have. There is a difference, of course; Alex in Burgess's work is essentially tortured into being something other than what he is, whereas this guy is literally repaired.
I think that scenario leads to a pretty good Trek-style ethical debate. I suspect you might be thinking of the Brad Dourif episodes in wondering if they've done this on the series before. They have, but I don't necessarily mind the repeat; it's a topic worth thinking about every so often.
For my part, I don't know how I'd feel about this in the real world. I'm a liberal, but I don't mind the death penalty provided there's rock-solid evidence. Some folks just need killing. However, if there were a genuinely reliable path toward true rehabilitation, I'd probably want that to be the norm. Would I if somebody I loved had been the victim? I dunno; I'd have to get back to you on that when such a real-world scenario arises, which hopefully it never will.
(2) What puts this episode over the top for me is the way it serves as a good character episode for several of the main cast. Seven, obviously; I definitely feel her unresolved guilt over the actions she took as a Borg. But also Neelix, who is kind of heartbreaking at the end when he discovers his inherent goodwill has been abused. The Neelixes of the world have that happen all too often.
(3) I knew I knew Jeff Kober from something. Not "China Beach," in my case, so I had to look it up. He's been in lots of things, but what I was failing to think of was the X-Files episode "Ice." You yourself likely know him from the Always Sunny episode "Gun Fever Too," in which he plays a character plausibly named Creepy Guy.
I think he's pretty solid in this Voyager episode. He comes off as a genuine threat and lunatic in the beginning, but also conveys the change well.
(1) and (2) Good points.
Delete(3) I was wondering just this morning, for some reason, where you were at with your Always Sunny watching and whether you'd gotten to some episode that I now am drawing a total blank on.
(3) I'm somewhere around the end of season 3. Got so many shows in the hopper that I'm not seeing more than an episode a week, in most cases. Good stuff, though; I don't much mind prolonging my time with that particular show.
Delete"Prophecy" --
ReplyDelete(1) I guess you *might* be overranking this one, but if so, I'll join you in doing so. I love this one. It falls something short of being a classic, but it's one of those episodes that just kind of oozes with all the things I like about this particular era of Star Trek. Kind of the Berman-era equivalent of comfort food, I guess.
(2) I'm not always the biggest fan of Klingon episodes, but they tend to be pretty good on Voyager, where B'Elanna's mixed makeup tends to reframe the way they are viewed. And I really like the idea that these are fundementalist breakaway Klingons who are kind of spiritually driven moreso than blood-mad. Which is not to say that they aren't recognizably Klingon; they are. So their expedition set out from Kronos a hundred years or so ago. Where does that fall in the overall Trek timeline? Somewhere between Enterprise and TOS, I think?
(3) I just can't say enough about how into the Neelix plotline I was. I could have used maybe a little bit more of it, but it's probably the perfect amount as is. All the scenes of Tuvok being horrified by the events unfolding around him, too; gold. I bet those quarters of his smelled like burnt sweet potatoes at the end of the episode.
(4) Tom Paris does not make a convincing Klingon.
(5) Robert Beltran had it easy this episode. He did nothing other than get cold-cocked in the back of the skull. Poor Chakotay; it's like they forgot he existed at a certain point.
(3) I'm with you! On pts. 1 and 2, as well, but definitely the Neelix/ Tuvok Odd-Couple spin-off. Would've been gold.
Delete(4) He does not.
(5) I know Beltran was very unhappy and very vocal about it. He always claimed it led to diminished storylines for Chakotay. It's possible. He alienated Jeri Taylor, I think, who early on championed Chakotay, and I think that might have had some backlash. Just a theory. It's too bad, all around.
"The Void" --
ReplyDeleteI like this one a lot. As you say, it's a strong concept explored well. I like the fact that somebody was sensible enough to realize that Tuvok's position would lean toward considering becoming hunters instead of prey; it's nice when the writers of these shows remember what logic is, and remember also that it need not always be benevolent.
Another nice note: Neelix piping up and saying that he was the first member of the alliance, lo these many years ago. And so he was, the rascal. Good on ya, Neelix.
Good point re: logic!
DeleteCome to think of it, they never have Vulcan villains, do they? (I'm not counting Kim Cattral from TUC.) They just default to Romulan. That's a mistake; there should be a totally logical, totally Moriarty-type foil for the Federation. It's odd they never did this, in retrospect. Might as well forget about seeing it on Discovery or Picard.
"Workforce" --
ReplyDeleteI definitely could have used more exploration of the reasons behind all of this. Why was there a labor shortage? Why was it so vital to get all the work done? Why could some of it not be automated? I think the episodes get by fine without it, but a more complex set of concepts at the core of the story could only have helped.
I do like these episodes, though. It gives the actors some fun stuff to play, and that's always welcome. My only gripe is that I wish they had included the scene in which Tom finds out he's actually married to the cute pregnant woman he's been crushing on. Skipping straight to the end on that one was a missed opportunity.
Yeah that'd have been better, agreed.
DeleteI don't mind it when they just throw us the metaphor without fully fleshing out the concept, like a Cloud Minders or a World Is Hollow sort of deal. But here they have a two-parter to play with and it felt like they could have explored it much more. They get more backstory/ rationale sketched out in the single-episode where The Doctor is shanghai'd to be a doctor on that one planet than they do here, with two.
Yep, that one is significantly better. And that's not a slam on "Workforce," because it's solid; just not the classic it maybe could have been.
DeleteSpeaking of the Doctor, I forgot to mention how enjoyable a concept the Emergency Command Hologram stuff is. It's a logical -- though (like the EMH idea itself) kind of crazy -- progression of the conceit. Captain Shmullus for the win! Although they steal some of his glory and give it to Harry, I guess.
"Human Error" --
ReplyDelete(1) I'd say your comments on this episode are better than the episode, except I really like this episode a lot. I can see your point about it being too late in the series for this sort of thing, but I can't honestly say I agree. I mean, I *do* agree intellectually, but emotionally, this one works like a charm for me.
(2) Jeri Ryan. Hoo boy. I don't know what it says about me that I think she's the hottest she's ever been while wearing a science-division uniform, but there you have it.
(3) Ryan has terrific chemistry with Beltran. I'm not sure Beltran has terrific chemistry with Ryan, though. Weird, but maybe true. I say maybe because a part of me thinks Beltran might be playing some really subtle notes to distinguish the holodeck version of Chakotay from the actual version; in other words, he's putting a layer of falsity on top of things so as to emphasize that there's only one human being in the equation. Am I giving him too much credit? Probably. but hey, if it works.
(4) Alright, let me get even crazier for a second. Does the final scene almost imply that Chakotay knows what Seven has been doing in that holodeck? He sure does seem to be carrying himself like a guy who's illicitly found out that a girl is into him, and is trying to take advantage of it, but without letting her know that he knows about it. Once again, I might be reading too much into it. But I dunno, man. There's something there.
(5) On the subject of Cha-faux-tay (awful, Bryant; awful), I've got questions. How does a program that close to the real deal get programmed? Does Seven, or Barclay or whoever, set all the parameters somehow? Or do they do something like instruct the computer to build the most realistic possible version of Chakotay and tell it to use personal logs, performance reviews, and any other existing relevant data? I think that's a basically insane idea, but at the same time, I totally believe that someone like Seven -- or Barclay, or Geordi (ref. Leah Brahms) -- absolutely WOULD do that. Heck, we've seen 'em do it! So I guess I don't actually have any questions; I/we kinda already know how this works. This episode seems to me like it's taking the concept a little bit farther than it's been taken before. Fair game, I think, especially if it's used for character development.
(6) You know, on some level of the Tower -- and it's probably only on one -- there've been a steady stream of Icheb-and-Neelix movies ever since. One was a musical! That's a better level than this one, I think.
(6) Amen to that. I apologize to everyone for not writing a proper review of the episode and instead indulging in such a fantasy, but damn it, it's like the showrunners of 'Picard' actually cast around to see what fans thought, found this blog and its frequent mentions of Team Icheb, and stuck me in the eye with an icepick. (I took/ take it personally, ya dipshits!)
Delete(5) I've had many similar questions on the holodeck. Like in the Da Vinci episode, how can they create a Da Vinci who doesn't just create new things? Do they leave the holodeck on and let him (or Mozart) compose/ create? Or like you say here, how exactly does the holodeck get to create versions of the senior staff? Who puts the Chakotay program together, and from what? It's all very interesting.
(4) No, I get that impression, too. And how DOES he know? Chakotay's "secret ways of knowing."
(2) I agree.
And three cheers for Chafauxtay!
Delete(4) The likely scenario there is that he hears -- in a normal and acceptable performance-review type situation -- from Janeway that the reason why Seven has been fucking up lately is that she's been spending an egregious amount of time on the holodeck. So then he takes it upon himself, possibly with no ill intent, to find out more about the details of what she was doing. I'd like to think he closes that door quickly once he found out, but it was too late; he knew some stuff he shouldn't know. A breach of protocol and privacy, but a well-intentioned one.
DeleteEither that, or he was outright spying on her, and that wouldn't seem like a very Chakotay thing to do.
Apropos of nothing, I just watched a 1990 episode of "Freddy's Nightmares" in which Tim Russ plays a scientist named Dr. Picard.
ReplyDeleteNice. Wait a minute, though, are there still episodes of "Freddy's Nightmares" you haven't watched? I thought you knocked all of those off last October. Is this a different season, or a revisit?
DeleteNo, I've still got some left. I started watching last year, but progress has been slow. It's not very good, more often than not. I think I've only got three episodes left, though, so almost there! I was initially recapping them via blog post, but gave up on that pretty quickly.
Delete"Q2" --
ReplyDelete(1) I'm probably a little more forgiving toward this one than you are, but not by a whole lot. "Voyager" didn't do especially well by ol' Q. I don't blame the show as much as I blame the show's producers; it was a bad idea to bring him onto "Deep Space Nine," and it was a bad idea to bring him onto "Voyager," as well. That's a character/concept which should have simply remained a part of TNG with no further exploration.
(2) This particular episode isn't helped by the fact that the kid who plays Q is pretty bad. He's an actual de Lancie, so the casting has that going for it; but that's about it. Him calling Icheb "Itchy" and being called "Qball" in return is cringe-inducingly bad.
(3) I guess I *kind of* liked the bit at the very end where Janeway point-blank asks Q to send 'em all right back home, and he balks at the idea because it wouldn't be right. I mean, I don't really buy that as an excuse, but at least it's AN excuse, and at least Janeway did the responsible thing and asked.
(1) Q is like the Harry Mudd of the Berman years. It just makes no sense why they thought this character was so brilliant / ripe for return. But yeah: had they left him as only a TNG-thing, it'd have been better.
Delete(2) Just awful.
(3) If anything, Q should've sent them to a whole nother quadrant.
"Author, Author" --
ReplyDelete(1) Man, what a terrific episode. I'd seen it before, but remembered literally nothing about it, so I was worked upon by the various twists and turns. I go back and forth on the subject of whether I believe that an AI like The Doctor will ever actually be possible in the real world; I don't rule it out, but neither do I accept it as an inevitability. And since so many of the drives which govern human behavior are outgrowths of biological needs (of which an AI would presumably have none [though that's not to say there wouldn't/couldn't be some equivalent]), I'm skeptical that if and when they do arise they would behave in what we consider to be human fashion. So in some ways, I reject the very premise of this episode's argument.
(2) But that's fine, because it's not necessary to accept it as a foregone conclusion. All I've got to accept is that that's how it works in this particular story, and then wonder how I would react. And if The Doctor were talking to me, I do not doubt that I would react to him the same way I would react to a flesh-and-blood human being. I might dislike him, perhaps intensely; I might be afraid of him, potentially; I might avoid him altogether. Or I might not do any of those things, depending on various factors. But even if I had the most negative and extreme reaction, it would be a reaction of a human nature; and reacting to him in that manner seems to me like the definition of assigning personhood to him.
(3) All the non-Doctor character stuff is great in this episode, too, especially the goofy alternative hairstyles. Nice to see Roxann Dawson out of makeup; nice to see "Tulok" in an evil goatee; nice to see Trill Harry Kim (not to mention getting an explanation for his still being an ensign!); nice to see Seven as a bimbo triplet; nice to see Seven forming a tentative bond with her aunt; nice to see mustachioed Tom Marseilles (genius, cannot WAIT for the Delta Flyers episode on this one); and nice especially to see Janeway stick up for the personhood of The Doctor even after he's kind of been a dick toward her. And the fact that it is Neelix who gently convinces him to make the revisions is perfect; even in season seven, Neelix can be a secret weapon.
(4) Not much for poor Chakotay to do, though, which is a shame.
(4) Yeah he's basically out of the show at this point. Practically.
Delete(3) Agreed on this one being a fun Delta Flyers episode to look forward to. And yes, excellent use of Neelix.
(1) and (2) Very interesting observations here. I kind of agree - I don't really think "photonic life" will ever really just be an alternate version of people. I think BSG gets that closer to how it will probably go! They'll have their own religion and their own truths and needs and motivations. And long memories. I'm super-polite to Siri for this very reason!
(4) I kind of remembered that happening in the seventh season, and yep, sure enough.
Delete(3) I'm listening to this week's now (on the subject of the second season's "Prototype") and Wang just introduced the saying "Once you go robot you never say 'No, bot!'," which cracked me up. Good stuff.
(2) I am picturing Montgomery Scott speaking into a mouse very politely but with an underlying edge of impatience.
(3) I believe he says "Blacks don't cracks; Asians don't raisin" in the same episode. Not as good as the "once you go robot..." line but he's clearly enjoying himself over there. As am I - good podcast.
Delete(2) I love that scene so much. I always wonder what the deal is with the lady who comes in during that scene. "NOT NOW, MADELINE!" Poor Madeline! I digress.
(4) Sorry, I'm out of order with my number points here... I think there's one Chakotay episode still to come, actually, I'm wrong. But generally speaking, yeah, I think the actor and the writers/ directors weren't seeing eye to eye by s7. Too bad. Actually speaking of TDF Beltran was way less combative/ much friendlier in his appearance on the episode he was on than he has been in some other interviews I've seen/ read.
(3) Holy crap, I missed that, somehow.
Delete(2) I have a vague memory of there being a scene in the novelization that addressed that, but I have no earthly idea what it was. Something to look forward to in the year 2067, when Where No Blog Has Gone Before finally gets to "The Voyage Home" and investigates the issue further.
(4) I suspect Beltran's discontent with the show is limited to certain parameters. And I doubt that being around his castmates is one of them. Plus, I'd imagine that with the show having a bit of a resurgence currently, he's probably getting a fair amount of love from fans new and old alike. Nobody sends hate mail for a 25-year-old show, but lots of people send love letters for one. So I hope he's getting his fair share!
" Nobody sends hate mail for a 25-year-old show, but lots of people send love letters for one."
DeleteVery true! And emblematic of bigger truths about art, love, and humanity, I think.
"Friendship One" --
ReplyDeleteSolid, if maybe a little unremarkable, episode. There's pretty much nothing here that doesn't work for me; all the characters are used pretty well (the entire cast gets at least one nice moment), and the ethical dilemma seems genuine enough. I can't say I blame the remnants of that civilization for being murderously cheesed off at humanity; and their fate is a good argument in favor of the Prime Directive eventually having been adopted.
The only complaint I would have is that they missed an opportunity with Lt. Carey. I had to look this up to be sure he's who I was thinking of, but he's the guy back in the first season who lost the Chief Engineer job to B'Elanna. This episode could have been a good opportunity to kind of resurrect that plotline and bring it to a full close. But it makes sense that B'Elanna stayed onboard, so even this isn't really a complaint; just a thought I had, is all. Agreed, by the way: that final note hits home.
Excellent point re: Lt. Carey! I wish they had done that. A missed opportunity.
Delete"Natural Law" --
ReplyDeleteNothing much to dislike here, if anything. Everyone behaves in more or less the only logical fashion; it's a situation that deprives them of being as rigorously adherent to the Prime Directive as they would be normally, which on the one hand means the episode has no bite to it, but on the other hand is well-made enough that that doesn't matter. It didn't matter to me, at least.
Regarding the shuttlecraft loss, I was considering making an argument that this one should be chalked up to Seven, since she is piloting. But they only get in that situation because Chakotay wants to sightsee, so I think you've assessed it correctly after all.
Yeah I liked this one, too, although it took me a minute to remember it, even looking at the screencaps again.
DeleteThe shuttlecraft thing gets a little something-or-other by season 7. It's just strange that they can replicate shuttles. Seems too far to me. But this was Ron Moore's argument, I bet. If it wasn't for VOY and DS9, we'd never ahve gotten BSG. So! Keep losing those shuttlecrafts, Chakotay, and keep replicating them, Voyager.
"Homestead" --
ReplyDelete(1) I'm with you; I think they do Neelix's sendoff awfully well. It's almost a little miracle of an episode. It really shouldn't work anywhere near as well as it does, and yet, here we are enthusing over it. I remember the first time I watched the episode -- I was a bit gutted that Neelix was staying behind rather than going with the crew for the rest of the voyage. And my journey with him that first watchthrough was a bit like yours in that I really didn't like him much at all. So when I got to that point and found myself actively being upset by the thought of him leaving, I was like, wait, WHAT? But ol' dude really is a secret weapon; he sneaks up on you and gives you a bearhug and your knee-jerk reaction is "boy, I just HATE this," except then you realize that at some point you started hugging him back and slapping his shoulder in a brotherly fashion while fighting back manly tears. No other character quite like him in all of Star Trek.
(2) I like the fact that his sendoff episode is begun by one of the most annoying Neelix scenes in the entire series: that business of him dancing at the jukebox. I can practically hear director LeVar Burton saying, "Alright, what we want here is for Neelix to be like a sentient kidney stone. We want him to be so embarrassing that you can imagine engagements being called off when the brides-to-be discover their fiances watching something so lame." And Ethan Phillips nods and says, "Oh, don't worry. I got this." Then he gets it, hard. And then, somehow, they manage to bring it back at the end and have it be so touching that the fiancees are begging their grooms-to-be to take them back, it was all a big misunderstanding. Hell of a move.
(3) That scene between Janeway and Neelix in which the Captain invents a bogus position on the spot so as to give Neelix the permission to do something he's struggling to do is the best scene Janeway has had in a while. Tim Russ is awfully good in this episode, too.
(4) Naomi Wildmon's mom must be a real sack of shit. she never seems to have any involvement with her daughter whatsoever, and can't even be bothered to be present when her full-time babysitter is departing forever. I blame her negligence for his not wanting to stay. Well, that and the promise of hot Talaxian nookie, of course.
(2) That is perfect. Thank you.
Delete(1) Oh, and definitely agreed - a unique regular cast member.
(3) and (4) Amen and amen.
"Renaissance Man" --
ReplyDelete(1) Isn't there an episode of TNG where Data gets taken over that's kind of similar to this one? Trek kind of blends together sometimes. I could just research the matter and not sit here in mild confusion, but I'm feeling lazy.
(2) I've kind of got a problem with how easy the Doctor gets off for disobeying Janeway's orders. I mean, it's not like his program has been overwritten or anything; he's making a conscious choice to disregard her express orders, thereby placing the entire ship in jeopardy. He should be court-martialled and tossed out of the service. Not that they ever do that sort of thing on these shows; nor that I would actually want those things to happen. But they really ought to.
(3) Have we seen those potato-looking aliens before or am I mixing them up with some potato-looking aliens from "Doctor Who"? (Again with the laziness.)
(4) I agree that it is in some ways an odd choice for a penultimate episode. At the same time, most of the characters get nice moments to play: Chakotay's role here is better than is typical of much of the season, Tuvok's cool in his one notable scene, Tom and B'Elanna get to be flirty, and you even get to see Harry commanding the ship temporarily. So in a sense, you could do worse. Not a favorite episode, but not a bad one.
(1) Hmm. Off the top of my head, I know Data's taken over to deliver himself to Lore/ Soong in one episode, and another where he's taken over by those aliens who also take over Troi and O'Brien. Are either of those what you're thinking of?
Delete(2) Good point.
(3) Yes, we saw them in "Tinker Tenor Doctor Spy". I think that's it, but the HIerarchy are mentioned quite a bit in s7.
(4) I'm surprised to re-discover I ranked this one as high as I did, and looking over my original entry I see I lost my notes for it. I wonder if my score was for these reasons you mention? It ticked off a good amount of boxes. I also to err on the overrated-side of caution with Doctor episodes, I guess.
You're one episode away!
Delete"Endgame" --
ReplyDelete(1) Well, here I am at last. For the second time, actually; but I remembered virtually nothing about this finale, so it may as well have been the first. Actually, I remembered one thing: that I disliked it, and rather intensely. And you know what?
Not so much this second time! I kind of had fun with it on repeat.
That said, I can't find much fault with anything you said here. I'm not sure there actually is any consistency with "Voyager" when it comes to the Borg and time travel and that sort of thing. However, I do think the show did a consistent job of making its crew feel like a family, and this finale hits that note frequently and (for my money) convincingly. So while I wouldn't rank this as a particularly great episode of the series, I think it makes for at least an okay finale.
(2) You know what worked for me pretty well this time, much to my surprise? The Chakotay/Seven romance. Both actors sell it fairly well. I'm sure we'll eventually learn on "Picard" that they split up because Chakotay died in an industrial-press accident or some other depressing thing. (Or, more likely, we'll never hear the name "Chakotay" again, which in its way is even more depressing.)
(3) I kind of feel bad for Susannah Thompson not being in this episode. I mean, by all means, if you can get Alice Krige than get Alice Krige. But Thompson did a nice job as the Queen, and I kind of hate for her to get shunted to the side in the dadgum finale.
(4) Captain Harry Kim! Goddamn right. But what if he never gets that promotion now thanks to this future-altering escapade? He's been robbed! (For that matter, does Naomi Wildomn's daughter get erased from existence now? Will Dr. Joe ever meet that blonde he marries?)
(5) Kate Mulgrew was pretty good in this one, I thought. A little arrogant as Admiral Janeway, but not in an inappropriate or inconsistent manner. Pretty good job of distinguishing between the two, I think.
(6) My big complaint: it ends too abruptly. It needed about ten more minutes of coda. As is, it feels anticlimactic. And I don't think they did a great job of making it clear what was going on: which, I assume, is that they suckered the sphere into going to the Alpha quadrant and then followed them, secure in the knowledge that they could use the future tech to blow 'em to hell. But wouldn't that tech have winked right out of existence the moment they entered the Alpha quadrant? Ah, well, never mind, it's all phooey anyways. But I think they could have hit all of this a little harder to make it function as a plot twist followed by triumph, and then had some wrapup to carry us all the way out.
All things considered, though, I did like this, certainly more than I did the first time I saw it, in the mid '00s.
And no matter what, it's a fine series which comes to an end here. I've very much enjoyed it on this revisit, especially following in this blog's footsteps. To the journey!
(1) I think it's important to hit that "family" note, but the way they did that in "Endgame" failed to move me. But that's a how-it-hits-you thing, so if that lands with other viewers, all the better, I say. The end of "All Good Things" makes me tear up with such sentiments; I project my entire life on the screen, all my feelings on the show, etc. Same with "Daybreak" for BSG or the end of "Larry Sanders" or so many other great-finales. But "Endgame" just doesn't hit me like that. I still feel the VOY cast needs a proper send-off.
Delete(2) Considering that intersectionality has seemed to replace the prime directive for Discovery et al, I'm surprised they'd not bring up Chakotay, but more likely they want to set Seven up as a lesbian. I'm sure there will be much vocal support for that among many Discovery watchers, though probably for varying reasons.
(3) Good call. Someone should cast Robin Curtis and Susannah Thompson in something together.
(4) through (6) Good call on all these points. To the journey indeed!
After I get my DS9 s7 post up (which has accumulated a lot of dust at this point since I did the first draft half a year ago) I'll start in with ENT; the journey continues...!
(1) I think it probably worked better for me in the future timeline than in the "present" one, so I kind of agree -- it could have been more successful than it is. But I think this time, it worked well enough for me that it washed a lot of the bad-finale taste out of my mouth. It's no BSG, though, or TNG, for sure.
Delete(2) Oh, they've already indicated that they're gonna play the Seven-is-gay card. Which, fine by me if it's done well. But I doubt it will be done well.
Looking forward to following along with Enterprise!
(1) You know, thinking about this further, something occurred to me: much of the feeling you mention missing IS present. Not in this episode, though: you get it in "Homestead." In other words, I think "Endgame" may serve as another piece of proof that Neelix is secretly the soul of the series. I'm not immediately certain how having him onboard for the final episode could have changed things -- unless it was for it to be him rather than Seven who Janeway was desperate to save -- but even so, I think it would have.
ReplyDeleteHear, hear! Agreed completely. They should have found a way to combine the two into the finale. "Homestead" would have provided what was missing, emotionally.
Delete"Endgame" reminds me of other Berman-era miscalculations (from my POV) like "Nemesis", where so many of the elements add up/ must've sounded foolproof on paper, and then you see it all and something just doesn't add up. For me anyway.
Delete